“I’m a matchmaker – these are the 6 things that eliminate the possibility of a second date” 

ARTICLE BY FLEURINE TIDEMAN 

Forget whether you made a good impression. Did they? A matchmaker with more than a decade of experience explains the six first-date behaviours that should make you think twice about a second.

While on a first date, it’s easy to spend the whole evening wondering whether they like you. Are you laughing at the right moments? Did you over-share about your ex? Is there spinach in your teeth? You can get so caught up in making a good impression that you forget to check whether they’re making one too.

If a first date is an audition, both of you are trying out for the lead role of love interest, and you’re also on the casting panel. You can’t do that job properly if all your attention is on your own performance. Chemistry matters, but it isn’t the only thing to look at. How they treat the waiter, how they talk about other people and whether they ask you a single question back can tell you a lot more than how they look under candlelight.

So what should you be watching for? Stylist asked Molly Davis, vice president of client relations and matchmaking at Kelleher Matchmaking. She has more than a decade of experience helping high-net-worth and accomplished singles navigate modern dating and build lasting relationships. Here are the six first date red flags that would stop her recommending a second date.

1. Not being fully present

It sounds obvious, but showing up properly matters more than we think, and Davis sees dates as something to make an effort for.

“I have always encouraged clients to honour dates as special occasions, rather than something you squeeze in between walking the dog and meeting a friend for a drink,” says Davis. “Someone is inviting you to get to know them, and both individuals are investing their time and energy to explore whether there might be potential for something more.”

Avoiding eye contact, glancing at your phone or failing to make the person opposite you feel like the most important person in the room is, in Davis’s view, a disservice to both of you. And honestly, hard relate.

“It signals that this part of your life may not be a priority or that you’re simply not that invested in the opportunity,” Davis says. “These behaviours can reveal a lack of respect for other people’s time, a general lack of awareness or an inability to be present. If being intentional and engaged is important to you, this could point to a deeper incompatibility in values.”

The lesson: that phone shouldn’t be on the table, not even face down.

2. A lack of kindness and consideration for others

This is a popular one on social media, where it’s usually summed up as ‘watch how they treat the waiter’. Davis agrees, but she’s looking at more than the server.

“Being on a date with someone who doesn’t seem to notice they’re bumping into the table behind them, breezing past others in line or being rude to waitstaff can be a concerning signal,” she says.

“The way we interact with the people around us says a great deal about who we are. It reveals whether we value consideration, awareness, empathy and kindness. I pay attention to how someone treats people from whom they have nothing to gain. Those interactions can be incredibly telling.”

It might be failing to thank the bartender, shoving past people on the way to the loo or making snide comments about the couple at the next table. Each one on its own seems small, but together they show you who someone is.

“If kindness and consideration are important values to you, a lack of these qualities may be a sign that this isn’t your person,” Davis concludes.

3. A lack of curiosity

We’ve all been on the date where you could have swapped yourself for a cardboard cutout and the other person wouldn’t have noticed.

“If your date does most of the talking, shares endlessly about themselves, and doesn’t ask many questions about you, it’s worth paying attention,” says Davis. “It may signal that their interest isn’t as mutual as you’d hope.”

She’s quick to cut people some slack for first-date jitters, though. “Of course, nerves can get in the way. Sometimes people overtalk or get caught up in sharing because they’re trying to make a good impression. But there should still be some natural curiosity and an effort to get to know one another.”

So if your date leaves the bar without knowing what you do for work, whether you’re a dog or a cat person or how many siblings you have, take note. For Davis, this goes beyond polite etiquette. In her line of work, curiosity is a sign of something bigger.

“Curiosity is an important ingredient in a reciprocal partnership,” she says. “It reflects interest, emotional engagement and a willingness to continue learning about another person. It’s also a quality often associated with intellectual openness and lifelong learning.

“If someone shows little curiosity about your life, experiences or perspective, it may be a sign that they’re not ready for the kind of engaged, reciprocal partnership you’re looking for.”

Put simply, your future partner will want to know all about you.

4. Lifestyle incompatibility

Whether you’d date a smoker or – perhaps more likely these days – someone who vapes is a famously divisive question. Davis thinks it’s worth taking seriously, though less because of the habit itself than because of what it might say about how someone lives.

“Smoking, drinking habits or other substance use can be important indicators of lifestyle compatibility,” Davis says. “I like to think that most people are on their best behaviour when they’re on a date. So, if someone is drinking considerably more than you are, for example, or engaging in behaviours that don’t align with your lifestyle, it’s worth taking note.

“This isn’t necessarily about judging someone’s choices. It’s about recognising that the way we spend our free time, approach health, enjoy ourselves and define moderation can have a significant impact on a relationship.

“These differences may seem manageable in the early stages of dating, but over time, they can become meaningful sources of friction. If your lifestyles and values don’t align in these areas, there may be a larger compatibility issue.”

Six months in, it’s not about the smell of tobacco in their car but the money spent on cigarettes that could have gone on a trip together. It’s not about one glass of wine too many but the hangover that writes off your plans the next day. Davis urges us to look at the bigger picture rather than judging each behaviour on its own.

5. Not respecting personal boundaries

Most of the other red flags here are about compatibility. This one is about safety. A date who ignores your boundaries in a busy restaurant with other people around isn’t likely to respect them more once you’re alone.

“If your date isn’t picking up on your verbal or nonverbal cues about what’s comfortable for you, I would think twice about pursuing a second date,” Davis says.

“Perhaps a subject comes up that makes you uncomfortable and you try to redirect the conversation, but they continue to push. Or perhaps they don’t respect your lack of reciprocation when it comes to physical touch. These are behaviours worth taking seriously.”

It can be subtle: a hand left on your knee after you’ve shifted away, questions about your exes or your body after you’ve changed the subject, or pressure to have ‘just one more’ drink or go back to theirs. Most of us were raised to be polite and smooth things over, so we explain it away in the moment. Davis argues that you shouldn’t have to spell out your limits for someone to notice them.

“Respecting boundaries requires awareness, emotional intelligence and a willingness to recognise that another person’s comfort matters. It’s not just about hearing the word ‘no’; it’s about being attentive enough to recognise when someone is uncomfortable in the first place.

“If you’re someone who is perceptive and sensitive to the cues of others, you’ll likely need a partner who demonstrates that same level of awareness and consideration. A disregard for boundaries early on can signal a much deeper issue around respect and emotional safety.”

If your gut tells you something felt off, trust it. That’s reason enough not to book a second date.

6. Poor communication and lack of follow-through

According to Davis, the date starts long before you arrive.

“Dating behaviour starts well before you actually sit down across from someone. How a person communicates leading up to a date can tell you quite a bit about their level of interest and intentionality.”

These days, that means the Hinge chat beforehand, the effort that goes into arranging the date and whether they actually suggest a bar or restaurant. A friend once told me she cancels if someone suggests meeting at a station and ‘seeing where the night takes them’.

If they can’t pick a place, she isn’t turning up.

Davis agrees. “If someone doesn’t respond to an invitation, confirm details, communicate changes in plans or offer a simple thank-you or follow-up afterward, I would consider that worth noticing. These small gestures can reflect how seriously someone takes the opportunity to get to know you.”

That doesn’t mean going back to old-fashioned rules about which gender texts first or plans the date.

“That said, I always encourage both parties to participate in communication rather than establishing rigid rules about who should initiate, how quickly someone should respond or who should make the next move.”

“The bigger question is whether there’s a sense of mutual effort, consideration and follow-through. If you’re someone who values clear communication and consistency, a mismatch in this area could become a recurring source of frustration in a relationship.”